I really wanted to like Illustrado. I'd read the reviews, how it was spoken of almost-but-not-quite as The Great Filipino Novel. I thought it'd be like a Nick Joaquin story for the 2000s, maybe a sort of
On The Job on paper.
Not exactly, it turns out. Maybe it's just me, but (and I hate to be reductive about this) it was just so insufferably... konyo.
The book begins with the death of Crispin Salvador, some sort of enfante terrible of Philippine letters. Everyone thinks he killed himself by jumping in some New York river, but his student (also named Miguel Syjuco like the author *insert eye-roll here*) thinks something else might be up, maybe murder, and it might have to do with some unpublished novel Crispin was writing that was going to blow open the door on the dross in Philippine society and politics. So Miguel leaves his intellectual life in New York to return to the third world and find answers.
Nice set up, no? You think you're starting a journey into a compelling murder mystery, where we also get a peek into the dark underbelly of the ample crime and corruption found in Imperial Manila.
Instead we get a lot of - I don't know how else to put this but - whining about the Spanish-Filipino condition. We get flashbacks into the life of both Crispin and Miguel, their cushy lives as the spawn of landed elite, what drove them from the Philippines, how they settled into still-cushy lives in the West, how Miguel wanted to strike out on his own so he moved out of his grandparents' (god) Trump Tower apartment in New York to prove he was a big boy, etc., etc.
I'm not going into detail here, you read the book if you want that. But there was nothing relatable or identifiably Filipino about this book. There was a lot of existential angst about how it's so hard to be a poor little rich Spanish Filipino boy, a lot of details on the unrelatable, dripping-with-wealth life Spanish Filipinos apparently live in the Philippines (I had no idea), and everything else was sort of in the periphery.
What's going on in this book dudepare?
The book would segue into snippets of political goings-on in the background, with some president who is some sort of composite of Gloria Arroyo and Joseph Estrada, and his shenanigans with some starlet and some businessman, and that would have been interesting, but the book only goes into it in passing. Then we return to the dreary meanderings of Miguel and his musings about how hard his life somehow is.
The book is confusingly structured, Miguel's story interspersed with snippets from various "books" Crispin has written, as well as a fictionalized account of what is actually going on with Miguel. It makes for bewildering reading, so that I couldn't really follow the main story because we kept segueing into these "excerpts." Some of them might have actually made for interesting stories deserving of their own books. Instead, we get them smashed in here, half-stories that distract from the main plot.
There is also a cruel running joke throughout the book, one of those "A Lasallian, An Atenean and an AMA student walked into a bar" things that was popular when I was in college. You know the one, that "elite" university students would tell each other to feel good about themselves, where the AMA student is the butt of the joke for being too poor, too provincial, too bad at English, etc. I was waiting for it to go somewhere witty or insightful. Instead, it turned into some parody of what I guess the author thinks is the "low-quality" of some Pinoy immigrants who move to the US (because the AMA student moved to the US but he's still so bakya, hyuk, hyuk).
There is a part towards the end (page 207) where the characters have a nice discussion that's kind of a dissection of modern Filipino novel-writing. I liked that, I'll give the book that much. I folded the page so I could more easily find the one part I could appreciate.
The book ends confusingly, and I'm only putting in here what I think happened, I can't be sure. Turns out all the meanderings of Miguel were being written (I think?) by Crispin, who is alive and well. Meanwhile, it was Miguel who was found dead in the Pasig River, and Crispin decided, I don't know, that he wanted to immortalize his student on paper? Also he burns his unpublished novel, the macguffin that started this whole quest, so I guess we'll never know his insights into Philippine society.
Crispin is portrayed throughout as some kind of literary wild child, hated by the Philippine literary establishment for... I'm not sure actually. Is it because he wrote about the ugliness in Philippine society? Because he only had one big successful novel? Because he left the Philippines and lived in the West while writing about it? Because he's rich? I have no idea. We're just expected to take it as fact that this guy is some kind of giant whose every step shakes the local literary scene, all the way from his tenured teaching position in New York. Everyone hates him, basta, don't ask too many questions.
I'm sure white people enjoyed this as some kind of magical realist window into the steamy tropical monstrosity of Philippine society. But as a Pinoy, really, I have no idea what to make of this book. At the end of the day, I think the author was writing about his existential angst as a writer, of wanting to achieve greatness from this, of his conflict being "woke" but also part of a rich political family (his dad is Augusto Syjuco, Jr., formerly head of TESDA, last I heard also facing graft cases with the ombudsman).
It's a story about him, basically. A confusing, meandering, navel-gazing story.
But it's not really about anything Filipino. At least nothing that I recognize. If you're an Atenista driving an Audi at age 18, living in Urdaneta Village, or your grandparents built a seven-story mansion in Iligan and filled it with art, or you have maids that take turns fanning you in the veranda of your hacienda, maybe you'll get something out of this book.
But if you want a recognizable story about our country, the one that you see out your window, out your jeepney, out the MRT while you commute to work with one million people, look elsewhere.