Tuesday, June 06, 2017

I wanted to like Alien Covenant but then I got drunk

And drinking always brings the truth out.

I'll admit I liked Prometheus. But more because of the promise it held. At the end of that flick, we saw the scientist Shaw blasting off to the planet of the engineers with the head of the robot David to find out why they made us, and why they decided we were horrible and needed to be killed off (personally, I think it's because we developed shows like Keeping Up With the Kardashians). I like these "Ancient Aliens made us" stories, and I thought we'd pick up there in this new flick.

Not quite.

There are no spoiler warnings here, because the formula for Alien Covenant is every other Alien movie: (1) A foolish crew detours to a planet, and (2) encounters weird shit, before (3) being impregnated and slaughtered by xenomorphs until (4) a woman saves the day. Which, don't get me wrong, I enjoy, but that's what I have the other Alien movies for. This was supposed to be different.

Okay, fine, minor spoilers: David is a psychopath and he made the xenomorphs! *cue ominous music*

It seems David thinks his creators (humans) are weak and so, therefore, their creators (the engineers) must be even more shit. So, upon arriving on their planet, he immediately kills everyone with the black sludge from Prometheus. Then he uses the sludge and Shaw's body to experiment with making xenomorphs (yes, he cut up the woman who saved him). After this, he sends out a crappy recording of Shaw singing "Country Road" to lure humans to his planet, so they can be impregnated by the facehuggers, and birth the xenomorphs we all know and love.

My face after I realized what was going on.

I was prepared to accept this story, but then my boyfriend took me out drinking and kept pulling at strings until it all unraveled. My drunken mind gave me the clarity to look past my hipster need to say I "got" this Very Intelligent Movie™ and ask such things as:

  • Why does David need to lure humans to his planet? What are the chances humans would be flying past his planet anyway?
  • Wouldn't it be better to use the engineer technology and spaceships he has access to to fly to Earth and carpet-bomb the whole place with facehuggers, if he needs humans to grow the perfect xenomorphs?
  • Why did they set up this "Where do we come from?" mystery at the end of Prometheus if all we're getting is a less-than-5-minute flashback of David killing the engineers immediately, before they can explain anything, and a few offhand lines and pictures showing he killed Shaw?
  • For that matter, why even go through all the trouble of developing a xenomorph? After he used the black sludge to kill the engineers, why not just fly to Earth in the same spaceship and kill all humans the same way?

See, this is what happens when you take something good and try to explain too much and tie everyone to everything. Alien doesn't need to be explained. Alien is a terrifying monster. We don't know where it comes from, all we know is it wants to tear us to shreds. Sort of like the people who like Mocha Uson's blog.

They even had a sort-of explanation in Prometheus they could have used to explain the xenomorphs - they come from the black sludge. The black sludge incubates inside whichever species and uses their DNA to birth whatever will best kill them. We could have then just inferred that this eventually made xenomorphs.

That's the problem with prequels (like the shit Star Wars ones): You get obsessed with explaining everything, you take the mystery (and fun) out of the story, and you set back any attempts to tell new stories. Neill Blomkamp of District Nine fame was going to tell an Alien 5 with Ripley in it. But then that got killed because Ridley Scott wanted to tell prequels. The next movie may even apparently be set in between Prometheus and Alien Covenant, so it seems we're not going anywhere soon.

But at least we got Michael Fassbender being creepy, and wearing a white body suit he can sit in without getting that bilbil we all get when we sit down and our stomach bunches up. Buti pa sya.

No comments: